Pick-ups

It’s quite a journey to turn the NG Solid into a kit that most people will be able to build. The main challenge is in making affordable pick-ups, and making them in quantity.

NG Solid magnetic pick-up
NG magnetic pick-up
NG Solid trumpet bridge with pick-up
NG Solid trumpet bridge with integrated pick-up

Each pick-up needs to have the same output, be easy to build and test and be robust against handling and assembly into an instrument. There will be people who like to make their own pick-ups and do all kinds of experiments, but I also want to provide pick-ups that you can just mount, connect to the internal amplifier (without soldering) and that will always work. For instruments like guitar or violin all kinds of off-the-shelve solutions are available, but for hurdy gurdy we don’t have this luxury.

I’m getting there though. The design is mature enough to make good reliable pick-ups for our own finished instruments. Now it’s just a matter of organizing, optimizing and scaling up, so that we’ll have enough pick-ups for the DiY kits.

Materials engineering

One of the larger challenges in building a Fortran or Cobol kit has always been about bending the top plate and the sides. When I designed the Fortran, I wanted the sides to be fully closed (so without the laser cuts that provide the flexibility on a BASIC or Linotte). I designed the shape of the instrument to have a gentle curvature, to make it feasible to use flexible plywood. The only thickness that is regularly available (7mm) is still pretty rigid though. For the top plate is was completely unsuitable, so the current top plates need to be bent with heat, humidity and patience.

What is flexible plywood?
Plywood is a sheet of wood that I built from different layers that are glued together. In low quality plywood, the inner layer may be pulp or otherwise irregular. This is unsuitable for musical instruments. The highest grade of plywood consists of very thin layers of wood, without any faults, which have been perfectly glued together in alternating orientations: this grade is certified and used for building propeller aircraft. This is what we use at Nerdy Gurdy. Just without the aviation certification, as we try to avoid flying hurdy gurdies :).

In flexible plywood almost all the layers have the same grain orientation: only the innermost layer is different, to add robustness to the material. This makes the material flexible in one direction, and stiff in the other, much like a tonewood soundboard.

flexible side

For the last year we have been working with our supplier to develop a custom 3mm birch plywood, that is sufficiently flexible for our instruments and has the same look and feel as the rest of the instrument. With some design changes here and there, we’re able to use it both as a top plate (soundboard) as well as for the sides.

We have already build a large batch of our own instruments with the new material, and it is so much easier! And an unintended extra benefit is that the soundboard has become significantly more resonant. Starting from v2.0 the Fortran and Cobol DiY kits will both use this material.

flexible top

Design for climate change

We’ve always used PLA as material for our 3d prints, for a number of reasons: it has great acoustic properties, it is bio-based (made from corn rather than oil), it sheds very little harmful gas or dust particles during printing and to boot it is very easy to print. Unfortunately it can not withstand temperatures above 60°C, so this summer a hot car in the sun was not a good place to leave an instrument, as a few people have experienced.

So since the summer I have been working hard on climate proofing our instruments. Here’s a picture of two instruments in our home-built “let’s call it a climate chamber :)”.

Fortunately some of my closest friends have been at the forefront of 3d printer development for the last 15 years, so I have access to great intel. After lots of testing I was almost ready to change all our parts to ASA. It has great temperature resistance and acceptable acoustic properties, although unfortunately it’s not as nice for people and planet.

But then I found this stuff: https://colorfabb.com/pla-hp-black. It’s regular PLA, but specifically improved for thermal resistance (I understand that it has to do with polymer chain length selection, leading to a certain crystallization behavior in the plastic matrix). It’s bio-based and even locally developed and manufactured! We are now in the process of changing to this new material, and will keep monitoring and improving the process.

NG Solid progress

For the past few months I have been steadily improving the NG Solid. I’ve decided to start sharing a bit more about what I am working on. In my first prototype there were some specific notes that sounded much louder than the rest of the notes. I realized that there must be some harmonic resonances involved. By making a Finite Element Model of the bridge, and fitting the model to the identified resonances I was able to identify the mode shapes.

FEA model of a Nerdy Gurdy Solid bridge.

The calculation model made it much easier to iterate on the bridge design, and it quickly became apparent that in order to achieve the required stiffness I needed to change material. Fortunately I had already been experimenting with printing Carbon bridges. As the model predicted, the carbon bridges have much higher resonance frequencies and the amplified signal is now stable across the frequency range.

NG Solid first pictures

I have been working on a solid-body electric for some time now, with great support from some very knowledgeable people like Rory Scammell and Jimi Hellinga (two of the biggest experts in the world on the combination of hurdy gurdies and electronics). It is starting to become pretty awesome, but there is some work to be done before I’m happy to release it and before we’re ready to make them in significant numbers. Here’s a picture of one of the prototypes though, together with the ‘ making-off’. I never expected the picture to come out so well (no editing involved).

Nerdy Gurdy Solid Cobol

Into the wild

A few years ago I took up the idea of building my own Hurdy Gurdy. Now I’m not much of a craftsman, so that might be a disadvantage. I am, however, a highly experienced mechanical engineer. My normal field is designing equipment for the high-tech industry, with customers around Europe, Japan and Silicon Valley in the US.

So I thought: why not use the tools of the trade, and create a Hurdy Gurdy using modern rapid prototyping technology: Laser Cutting and 3D printing? Would it be possible to create an instrument that is inexpensive to build, and still sounds well.

After about 4 years of working on it on and off, and 4 iterations, I am happy to say that the result is there. I’ve named it the Nerdy Gurdy, and I’m ready to release it into the wild.